Conscientious Commitment
-
Conscientious refusal or conscientious provision: We can’t have both
Ryan Kulesa, Alberto Giubilini https://doi.org/10.1111/bioe.13285 Abstract Some authors argue that it is permissible for clinicians to conscientiously provide abortion services because clinicians are already allowed to conscientiously refuse to provide certain services. Call this the symmetry thesis. We argue that on either of the two main understandings of the aim of the medical profession—what we will call “pathocentric” and “interest-centric” views—conscientious refusal and conscientious provision are mutually exclusive. On pathocentric views, refusing to provide a service that takes away from a patient’s health is professionally justified because there are compelling reasons, based on professional standards, to refuse to provide that service (e.g., it does not…
-
The Moral Asymmetry of Conscientious Provision and Conscientious Refusal: Insights from Oppression and Allyship
by Richard Matthews Abstract: Conscientious refusal involves decisions by healthcare workers, on grounds of their conscience, to refuse to provide legal, professionally permissible and safe health interventions to patients. Conscientious provision involves decisions by healthcare workers, also on grounds of conscience, to provide safe and beneficial healthcare to patients that is prohibited by law or policy. Some bioethicists believe that the moral issues governing both are identical, and that if one permits conscientious refusals, one should also permit conscientious provisions. This article argues that this assumption of symmetry is incorrect. To demonstrate this, it does the following: first, it establishes…
-
Conscientious commitment, professional obligations and abortion provision after the reversal of Roe v Wade
by Alberto Giubilini, Udo Schuklenk, Francesca Minerva, Julian Savulescu Abstract We argue that, in certain circumstances, doctors might be professionally justified to provide abortions even in those jurisdictions where abortion is illegal. That it is at least professionally permissible does not mean that they have an all-things-considered ethical justification or obligation to provide illegal abortions or that professional obligations or professional permissibility trump legal obligations. It rather means that professional organisations should respect and indeed protect doctors’ positive claims of conscience to provide abortions if they plausibly track what is in the best medical interests of their patients. It is the responsibility…
-
Conscientious Commitment to Women’s Health
May 2011. By Rebecca J. Cook and Bernard Dickens. Abstract Conscientious commitment, the reverse of conscientious objection, inspires healthcare providers to overcome barriers to delivery of reproductive services to protect and advance women’s health. History shows social reformers suffering religious condemnation and imprisonment to promote means of birth control, until access became popularly accepted. Voluntary sterilization generally followed this pattern to acceptance, but overcoming resistance to voluntary abortion calls for courage and remains challenging. The challenge is aggravated by religious doctrines that view treatment of ectopic pregnancy, spontaneous miscarriage and emergency contraception not by reference to women’s healthcare needs, but…
-
Conscentious Commitment to Women’s Health
by Bernard Dickens 12 April 2008, Lancet In some regions of the world, hospital policy, negotiated with the health ministry and police, requires that a doctor who finds evidence of an unskilled abortion or abortion attempt should immediately inform police authorities and preserve the evidence. Elsewhere, religious leaders forbid male doctors from examining any part of a female patient’s body other than that being directly complained about. Can a doctor invoke a conscientious commitment to medically appropriate and timely diagnosis or care and refuse to comply with such directives? We have become familiar with the opposite stance of conscientious objection:…